indie rock cafe

robert smith radioheadDo you ever feel like you're in a tug-of-war with two of your favorite rock groups because one of them disses the other? What about if the "disser" also takes a shot at you and everyone you know in the same breath?

Well, leave it up to Robert Smith, everyone's favorite aging rocker, who had more than just his usually bad hair day today.

In an interview with Music Radar, The Cure's frontman lashed out at Radiohead, saying he "disagreed violently" with their pay-what-you want model for their 2007 blockbuster release, In Rainbows. Smith said allowing fans to determine their own price to download the album was an "idiot plan."

"You can't allow other people to put a price on what you do, " Smith said. "Otherwise you don't consider what you do to have any value at all and that's nonsense. If I put a value on my music and no one's prepared to pay that, then more fool me, but the idea that the value is created by the consumer is an idiot plan, it can't work."

Not only is it just stupid to attack Radiohead fans - many of whom are probably Cure fans as well - but it's also stupid to talk like a diva when you're an aging rocker. Never mind that Smith spit on a growing movement that will only do more to allow the best, and the least greedy, musicians and groups to flourish creativity while expanding their fan base by offering a fair price for music. The old models are gone and they might leave musicians like Smith with them. It's been happening for a decade now.

Maybe it's hard to make any sense to someone who wears a bird's nest on his head. I think it would be awesome if Radiohead wrote a song in response called "Idiot Plan". It will definitely get plenty of attention, that's for sure.

Tell Me Why - Radiohead
Reckoner v2.0 (Diplo Train Wreck Remix) - Radiohead
Jigsaw Falling Into Place - Radiohead

Radiohead website
Radiohead MySpace

Listen to High-Quality 2008 Concert of Radiohead

If you are a RadioHead, listen to this transformational two-hour Radiohead concert broadcast recorded by NPR on August 28, 2008 at Santa Barbara Bowl. I was lucky enough to see Radiohead play in San Francisco during the Outside Lands Festival (in photo above, thanks to insdecelebs) two weeks after this featured show.

The SF show was the most amazing concert I've ever been to - well worth the chance I took to have my car towed to see Radiohead play in the fog drenched Golden Gate Park with tens of thousands of people.

NPR music critic Bob Boilen, in this concert review, (you also hear him on the broadcast) got it right. He compared the event as one of his favorite concerts since seeing Pink Floyd perform Dark Side of the Moon (who wouldn't have loved to have seen that one) decades earlier:

"What they [Radiohead] do better than any band is create a sonic adventure — a soundscape which, at its best, stretches time and allows the mind to wander and rejuvenate. I think of it as resetting the synapses. Creativity breeds creativity. When the music was over, I felt unboxed and changed and pretty darn happy. Drugs are overrated; music is underrated."


Labels: , , , , ,



eMusic's FREE Daily Download!

   February 24, 2009   

4 Comments:

At 9:14 AM , Anonymous Anonymous said...

Smith is a stupid ass...Radiohead rocks!!!!!!!!!!

 
At 6:39 PM , Anonymous Anonymous said...

robert smith is the idiot, not radiohead. hello?!

 
At 10:46 PM , Anonymous Unonymous said...

He didn't insult Radiohead fans; just Radiohead. He was brash and over the top about it, but I see where he was coming from.

 
At 12:45 AM , Anonymous Anonymous said...

R Smith's just giving his opinion. I wonder how much Radiohead made from that album? Lots of publicity no doubt, but how much real money?

Trent Reznor said when they released the Saul Williams album he co produced with the option of paying for it "if you wanted to", 82% didn't pay.

So much for relying on peoples good nature!

 

Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home

Older Posts
twitter indierockcafe
indirockfacebook
indie rock myspace
youtube indie rock
indie rock lastfm
indie rock itunes podcast

Download 25 FREE songs at eMusic.com!

Indie Rock Cafe on Facebook



blog advertising is good for you

Current and upcoming releases (US dates)

12/7/09 Ólafur Arnalds - Dyad 1909
1/12/10 Vampire Weekend - Contra
1/19/10 Cold War Kids - Behave Yourself EP
1/19/10 Spoon - Transference
1/26/10 Beach House - Teen Dream
1/26/10 Basia Bulat - Heart Of My Own
2/1/10 Los Campesinos! - Romance Is Boring
2/2/10 Midlake - The Courage of Others
2/9/10 Yeasayer - Odd Blood
2/23/10 Shout Out Louds - Work
2/23/20 Shearwater - The Golden Archipelago
3/2/10 Rogue Wave - Permalight
3/2/10 The Whigs - In The Dark
3/9/10 Frightened Rabbit - The Winter of Mixed Drinks
3/9/10 Ted Leo & the Pharmacists - The Brutalist Bricks
3/16/10 Drive-By Truckers - The Big To-Do
3/16/10 The Whigs - In The Dark
3/22/10 Jónsi - Go
3/23/10 She & Him - Volume 2
5/4/10 The New Pornographers - Together

Get NCAA Tournament Tickets at StubHub!
IRC Popular Playlists & Mixes
Hundreds of songs, artists and bands.

 - 2009 Indie Rock Songs
 - 2008 Indie Rock Songs
 - 2007 Indie Rock Songs
 - Ears To The Music
 - State of Music
 - Best Rarely Heard Indie Songs
 - Summer Indie Rock Mixes
 - Songs of Winter
 - Songs of Spring
 - Songs About The Moon
 - Halloween Indie Rock Songs
 - Indie Christmas Songs Compilation
 - Valentine and Love Mixes
 - Songs About New York City
 - Dream Playlist
 - Songs for Mom
 - The Great Unknowns
 -  Quickies

Regular Features
 - Best New Releases
 - Band of the Week
 - Singer-Songwriter Spotlight Series
 - Bands to Watch
 - In Dee Mail
 - One Man Bands

Dig The Music Archives




Indie Record Labels


See Sold-Out Shows! Tickets Available on StubHub.com